Fluoride Vote: Yes or No?
Fluoride Vote: Yes or No? Save Email Print
Grand Island
Posted: 7:00 PM Oct 28, 2008
Last Updated: 7:04 PM Oct 28, 2008
Reporter: Sara Geake
Email Address: sara.geake@kolnkgin.com

A | A | A

Voters in more than 60 Nebraska communities will decide whether to add fluoride to their drinking water.

Back in April state lawmakers passed a bill making it mandatory for communities of more than 1,000 people to put fluoride in their water.

But they also added an opt out provision, which the majority of communities are putting to a vote next week.

Officials say you won't be able to see or taste fluoride in your water once it's added, in fact, it's already there.

"The recommended rate is to fluoridate up to one part per million and currently the city water supply has between .5 and .6 part per million, so half to a little more is naturally occurring in the city's water supply," said Gary Mader, Grand Island Utilities Director.

But critics say adding more fluoride is dangerous.

"We know they're putting it in the water at 1 part per million, but we've also found that there are issues tied with fluoridation all the way down to .7 parts per million," said Chuck Carpenter, spokesperson for Nebraskans For Safe Water.

"They're finding things in China with lower I.Q. in children. They're finding forms of cancer in New Jersey where they've had a chance to do some severe studying."

But dentist David Lofgreen says at the recommended level fluoride is safe and beneficial.

"The general benefits to the individual are fewer areas of decay in the mouth and the benefit in extends out over ones lifetime," he said. "It's a benefit to society in general because of less cost involved in maintaining teeth of individuals who can't afford to have their teeth fixed."

And Lofgreen says, it's a savings that's proven.

"Hall County spends about $1.4 million a year on people for medicaid in taking care of teeth. Buffalo County spends about $800,000 and they fluoridated water," he said.

But does everyone need that daily dose of fluoride? That's a question the opposition is asking.

"It's a medicine being delivered to the people, and you set a dangerous precedent when you start mass medicating the public to get to a small segment of the population," said Carpenter.

The Centers for Disease Control supports water fluoridation, saying more than 180 million Americans drink fluoridated water.

On November 4th, a vote 'yes' is saying yes to a proposition to keep fluoride out of your drinking water.

A vote 'no' is saying you want fluoride in your water.

More Stories
Lance's Journal: One Woman's Treasure, July 6

Mayor Presents Budget to City Council

Governor Pushes Stimulus Funds To Increase Teacher Pay

Local Child with Diabetes Lobbies Congress

Bovine TB Tests Clean

Longtime Roads Department Employee is New Director

Eagle Man Dies in Crash

Neighbors Fight, Go to Jail

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: ann Location: England on Nov 3, 2008 at 06:41 AM
I hope Nebraska will not be fluoridated. Fluorosilicic acid, which is used in fluoridation schemes, is toxic waste taken from phosphate fertilizer factory chimney scrubbers. It is more poisonous than lead and only slightly less so than arsenic. It is not pharmaceutical grade, unlike the fluoride added to dental products. Adding fluoride directly to teeth has been shown to be much more effective than drinking it. Fluoridated areas have more fluorosis - permanent tooth mottling and more hip fractures. All medication should be prescribed individually - not given to whole communities, which goes against all medical ethics.

Posted by: Sheila Location: Lincoln on Oct 29, 2008 at 12:35 PM
Definitely a no brainer!

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 29, 2008 at 11:57 AM
Better take the floride out of toothpaste also.

Posted by: Scott Location: Lincoln on Oct 28, 2008 at 09:31 PM
Fluoride in the water, YES! Seems like a "No Brainer"

CarStar
What's On KOLN/KGIN
Special Features
Fourth of July Independence Day
Happy Fourth of July!
Community Calendar Community Calendar
Search and post upcoming community events
BryanLGH Healthy Everyday - BryanLGH
Health tips and stories
Wedding Information Bridal Boutique
Plan your wedding
It's Your Shot It's Your Shot
Share your photos
Buy It Nebraska Buy It Nebraska
Sell your stuff... buy some more!
Lance's Journal Lance's Journal
Nebraska's hidden treasures
Moms Everyday Moms Everyday
10/11 parenting stories and Serese Cole's Mom-to-Mom blog
It's Your Shot - Kids, Pets and Randoms!